Sunday, July 12, 2009

DAY 5: Saturday, June 11, 2009

Editor’s Note:

The volume of news continues to build. Here are some highlights reported from Saturday’s session.

From Christine Purcell:


Each day here brings so many memorable moments: for me, yesterday’s (Saturday July 11) was the address by Jenny Te Paa, the "ahorangi" or dean of Te Rau Kahikatea (College of St. John the Evangelist) in Auckland, New Zealand.


Dr. Te Paa was one of five international guests invited by Bonnie Anderson, President of the House of Deputies, to observe our 76th General Convention. The other four were from Brazil, South Africa, Ghana, and Kenya – the “true global south”, she said!

Dr. Te Paa spoke, softly and thoughtfully, words of embrace, affirmation, exhortation and gentle advice. You can read them in full at http://ecusa.anglican.org/79901_112408_ENG_HTM.htm, and I strongly encourage you to do so, to gain a sense of how others see us.


One of the great gifts of the way we do business here in the The Episcopal Church is that our process manages to be both egalitarian and transparent. Sure, politics are politics. But there are so many checks and balances – among them our bicameral structure, our strict adherence to Robert’s Rules, our overall commitment to civil discourse, consistently applied. Whatever is decided here, every attempt will have been made to hear all voices with loving respect, trusting that our fidelity to be gracious and generous will, in turn, enable the Holy Spirit’s grace and generosity to cover us all.


From Gina Barrett:


The Committee on Prayer Book, Liturgy and Music is considering several resolutions to do with same-gender blessings. There are two ways the commission can handle this: (1) to change the marriage canons so that marriage becomes a union between two adults rather than between a man and a woman; or (2) to develop a rite blessing same-gender unions. The challenge is to craft a resolution that both the House of Bishops and the House of Deputies will pass because, as you know, a resolution has to pass both in order to be enacted. In testimony two days ago, the majority of people spoke in favor of same-gender blessings. None of the resolutions have come out of committee yet.


Another set of liturgies under consideration is “Rachel’s Tears, Hannah’s Hopes”, designed to respond to pastoral concerns dealing with reproductive issues. One of these liturgies addresses the loss of children through miscarriage, stillbirth, abortion, adoption or inability to conceive. There is also a rite of reconciliation and repentance for an abortion. These rites are beautifully written and, if adopted, will be a wonderful resource for pastors and families struggling with life and death issues.


On a lighter note, today the commission heard testimony on two resolutions that would authorize prayers and rites for the loss of a companion animal. Eight people (two accompanied by service dogs) spoke eloquently in support of these resolutions.


In a session I attended a few days ago, members were considering amendments to newly-written collects and prefaces. I was struck by the care and concern given to each word and phrase, both read and chanted. It was painstaking work (some might say nitpicking), but if praying shapes believing, then great care must be taken. After all, this is our theology in liturgical form.


From Kate Harrigan:


In the past two days we passed two important pieces of legislation that will enhance our lives of faith in our diocese and in our congregations. The first is the Charter for Lifelong Christian Formation, a document that points to guide us in our theology and practice around Christian formation for ALL God’s people, cradle-to-grave.

The second is a resolution encouraging dioceses to develop strategies for lifelong formation. This gives “teeth” to the Charter, as it urges implementation. Thus we have both framework and encouragement to continue and broaden work in which we that we are already engaged, within our diocese.

Saturday, July 11, 2009

DAY 4: Friday, July 10, 2009

From David Lovelace:

Reflections on B033 Discussion: Today brought the second conversation of the whole for the House of Deputies on the controversy related to this resolution passed by the 2006 General Convention, which called on standing committees and bishops with jurisdiction to "exercise restraint by not consenting to the consecration to the episcopate of any candidate whose manner of life presents a challenge to the wider church and would lead to further strains on communion." The intent of the conversation was so deputies might listen to one another without political maneuvering.

I was struck by the careful and respectful sharing that took place around a very sensitive issue for many people. Some people are feeling frustrated that the Church is not willing to move faster and with prophetic courage. Others urge us to use caution and restraint when it comes to issues related to human sexuality.

What strikes me is that we are on a pilgrimage together to come to a better understanding of how to be loving and welcoming to all God's children. I am not sure legislation is going to solve this issue for the church. I believe the journey continues and we must be willing to listen carefully to one another. Perhaps the public narrative workshops at General Convention will assist us to hear one another's stories and to engage in a mission of providing justice for all people. Maybe those of us who are engaged in this process can return to our home dioceses to help all of us listen and engage in finding ways to be loving to all our neighbors.

From Legislative Aide Mary Amato

Editor’s Note: Mary has traveled with the deputation to Anaheim to participate in a vital way in this Convention – as one of the hundreds of volunteers who enable the wheels of process to turn smoothly.

You may nor may not be aware that General Convention is the largest bicameral body in the world. It functions the same as our own government does. Likewise, my Legislative Aide position is the same as it would be in our Congress. As a committee meets, the Legislative Aide assists in variety of ways as a support person. But my most important responsibility is to allow the committee to focus on their work and not on the tedious jobs of submitting the necessary paperwork for meeting postings, committee reports etc. As an aide, I have been asked to do such things as type meeting minutes, and follow-up on committee reports and responses back from the House of Bishops. I work closely with the officers of the committee.

This is my third convention serving in this capacity. Beyond enjoying the work as a Legislative Aide, I have learned much from the committee I am serving, Church In Small Communities. I have heard some powerful stories about the struggles, successes, and ongoing ministry in small churches throughout our own Episcopal Church.

From Diocesan ECW President Amy Swiernik:

Barbara Brinton, Bonnie Chambers and I have made it to California and have been busy the last few days.

The ECW Opening Celebration took place Wednesday afternoon, with President Kay Meyer officially opening the meeting for the 88 dioceses represented, with a total of 284 voting delegates present. The Presiding Bishop spoke to encourage and thank the women of the church for their integral part in the Anglican communion. The ECW welcoming dinner in the evening was highlighted with a wonderful play on the history of the ECW. We will be bringing home copies of the play that can be shared with the entire Diocese.

On Thursday, Archbishop of Canterbury Rowan Williams addressed the ECW, and he further emphasized the importance of the work being done around the world by the Women of the communion. After the Archbishop spoke, the representative of the Anglican Communion to the United Nations, Helen Wandusa spoke about the wonderful work that has been done, but also reminded us of the long road still have to go in just meeting the basic needs of many women around the world. We spent the afternoon in plenary session voting on By-Laws and listening to reports of the Nominating Committee, Resolutions Committee and President's message.

The meditations and sermons of the Rev. Dr. Ellen Sloan, ECW Chaplain, are being posted on the national ECW website. There is an ECW section in the Daily Episcopal Life that is being distributed here daily. It can be accessed at www.episcopalchurch.org

The honored woman ceremony took place Friday afternoon with Bishop Baxter and I escorting our own Barbara Brinton through the ceremony. It was a thrill to honor her. The official Youth Presence also addressed the ECW. They were very well spoken and full of hope for our church. UTO sharing dinner takes place this evening.

I am able to access email here if anyone would like to ask questions or has any comments. My address is amyecwcpa@comcast.net.

Have a fabulous day and blessings!



Friday, July 10, 2009

Moscow to Anaheim

According to news reports, when President Obama sat down earlier this week to talk with Russian Prime Minister Vladimir Putin, the first question Mr. Obama asked was, “So, how did we get here?” For the next forty minutes, Mr. Putin recounted his story of the last thirty years of U.S. - Russian relations. Mr. Obama began a dialogue by listening, and in doing so, he honored the views of his companion, however much the two may agree or disagree on specific issues at the moment.

In what may be a welcome turn from earlier form, it appears that there's a lot of the same sort of thing going on at the current General Convention, particularly regarding the topics related to sexuality. The deputies know that we must deal with the issue, but they also know that there are other pressing concerns, and that the viability of the Episcopal Church does not turn entirely on this one subject. The overarching theme of this convention might best be summed up as, “We're all in this together.” That's progress in and of itself.

Stay tuned for more updates.

DAY 3: Thursday, July 9, 2009

Editor's note: During the General Convention, members of the Central Pennsylvania deputation are providing daily updates to the Diocese. The Rev. Christine Purcell is serving as “recorder and reporter” for these updates.

From Deputation Chair Kate Harrigan:
Early in Convention, much of the work is being done in committee. Resolutions are being heard, deliberated and fine-tuned for later presentation on the floors of the House of Bishops and the House of Deputies. Your deputies are serving on or following committees devoted to ministry, liturgy, ecumenism, education, small congregations, national and international concerns, and communication, as well as a number of others.

Public Narrative Project:
In the second "Mission Conversation" with our table groups, we shared the stories of our lives that led to our call to mission and ministry. We were also coached in how to listen and give feedback to one another.


The Morning Eucharist:
The Archbishop of Canterbury preached, and Bishop Jon Bruno of Los Angeles presided. Bishop Bruno explained that whenever young people are present, he chooses a child or young person to stand with him at the altar while he celebrates the Eucharist. Today was no exception, as he celebrated with a young boy standing beside him. Worship over the last two days has included both English and Spanish in the liturgy, in song, in word, and in prayer.


“Committee of the Whole” Discussion of GC2006 B033:
During the afternoon legislative session, the House of Deputies used this mechanism to discuss, without debate, this resolution passed at the end of the last General Convention. It called for a moratorium on electing to the episcopate those whose manner of life would be challenge to others in the Anglican communion and a cessation of incursions by bishops from other churches in the communion into dioceses in the Episcopal Church (TEC). Each deputy sat with a person we did not know, to ask and answer three questions: (1) what is our own story with respect to B033 and its implications; (2) what is our story as a church with respect to the issue; and (3) what is God calling us to do now. This process of respectful speaking and listening will continue in the next legislative session.


There is little free time for deputies, bishops, volunteers and others as people rush from committee meeting to worship to legislative meeting. But there is much energy and a true spirit for the life of the church and for God's work, as thousands of people seek to be faithful to God's call to serve the world.


From David Lovelace:


The past two days have been filled with hearings on resolutions for the Ministry Legislative Committee. We have heard and discussed resolutions relating to education of laity, the discernment process for ordination, the dissolution of a pastoral relationship and funding for theological education. Despite the long days, progress is being made to support the many ministries related to the ministry of all the baptized. I am impressed with the desire of all to encourage and support persons as they seek to answer God's call to service. I look forward to the debate and outcome as these thirty plus resolutions come to the floor of the House of Deputies.

From Harry Snell:

The Committee on consecration of bishops consented to the election of The Rev. Luis Fernando Ruiz , Bishop of Ecuador Central.

From Christine Purcell

“There’s nothing new under the sun”, the poet writes in Ecclesiastes. The Standing Commission on Communication is wrestling with many complex issues in the area of communication that are familiar to many of us: internal communication, a management issue vs. external communication and public relations; print vs. electronic media; the implications of demographic differences, to name just a few. And then there are the people issues: lack of coordination leads to the failure of trust. “It’s not what you did, it’s how you did it...”.

The new director of communication at the Church Center put forward a draft budget that called for the “morphing” of Episcopal Life, the monthly diocesan newspaper, into Episcopal Life, the quarterly magazine at the end of 2009. Regular “news” would be communicated in other ways; the magazine could explore issues with more depth. The significant savings realized, with respect to staff resources, would allow more development and utilization of other communications media.


The plan has encountered significant resistance. Many believe that Episcopal Life, the monthly newspaper, has had and continues to have an essential role in dioceses where newer media are less effective due to geography and demographics; and even more importantly, in dioceses where it has been a potent symbol of connection to the larger Episcopal Church. For example, in one diocese its circulation was blocked by a bishop who eventually left the Episcopal Church, taking a number of parishes with him. In another, its display in peoples’ homes signified their resistance to prevailing attitudes with respect to future directions.


Committee discussions and an open hearing have fleshed out the issues and given voice to different constituencies. I am confident that, with an adjusted timeline and some clarification of lines authority, it will be sorted out in the end! In the meantime, it is fascinating to watch.

Thursday, July 9, 2009

General Convention - Day 2

Editor's note: During the General Convention, members of the Central Pennsylvania deputation are providing daily updates to the Diocese. The Rev. Christine Purcell is serving as “recorder and reporter” for these updates.

“Doing the business of getting ready to do business” pretty much sums up the opening legislative session. Appointments, the certification of a quorum, election of Secretary and Treasurer, adoption of a proposed schedule– the stuff that has to be in place so the House of Deputies can do the work of this convention, including but not limited to the consideration of literally hundreds of resolutions.

At the opening Eucharist the Presiding Bishop preached about heart transplants based on the text of Ezekiel 36: “A new heart I will give you, and a new spirit I will put within you; and I will remove from your body the heart of stone and give you a heart of flesh”. The primate of the Episcopal Church in the Philippines , once a constituent part of the Episcopal Church which became an autonomous member of the Anglican Communion in 1990, presented gifts to the TEC in thanksgiving for its support and in recognition of friendship and solidarity in the face of shared global economic challenges. There was, of course, wonderful music and a deep sense of the presence of the Spirit. This reporter’s high point: at the exchange of the Peace, turning from a warm greeting from a woman from the Diocese of Minnesota’s youth contingent to the outstretched hand of the Archbishop of Canterbury.

Late in the day, the PB Katherine Jefferts-Schori, ABC Rowan Williams, and three young leaders in ministry comprised a panel to addressing the impacts of our global economic crisis. William’s remarks centered around his conviction that it is first and foremost a crisis of truthfulness. On the most prosaic level, the business world no longer operates with any expectation of truth-telling between entities. With respect to our relationship with the world in which we live, we have not been truthful with ourselves and one another about the fact that it is limited; we spin the fantasy that endless expansion, production and profit are possible without cost. And finally, as we relate to one another, we have not been truthful about our interdependence and need for one another. More on his comments are available on Episcopal Life Online (ecusa.anglican.org/episcopal_life.htm).

Bearing witness to his remarks were Sarah Eagle Heart, the Episcopal Church's program officer for Native American/Indigenous Ministries, who spoke about the rising suicide rate among Native American youth; Michael Schut, economic and environmental affairs officer for the Episcopal Church who described the impact of the ecological crisis on those living at subsistence level on the edge of toxic waterways; and Dr. Stephen Dzisi, a physician and technical director for NetsforLife®, an Episcopal Relief and Development partnership program that fights malaria in sub-Saharan Africa.

Report on the Public Narrative Project from Stephen Casey:
In response to GC 2006 Resolution D043: Dialogue on Mission of the Church, participants in this 2009 Convention will engage in Public Narrative to enable articulation of and commitment to a greater vision for mission. Public narrative is a method by which individuals communicate values, appreciate the values of others, and draw on those values to act. The process begins with sharing our life stories with one another. Our stories are broken into three parts: the story of self; the story of us; and the story of now.

By telling the “story of self” we communicate why and how we were called to care. By telling the “story of us” we describe what in our community calls us to act; and our “story of now” communicates the urgent challenge we are called to confront as a community – right now. We all possess a story of self, of us, and of now.

The Province meetings which preceded this Convention began this process of Public Narrative, and some Bishops and Deputies volunteered to be trained as coaches to help facilitate this church wide conversation. From the Diocese of Central Pennsylvania, Gina Barrett, David Lovelace and Stephen Casey have been trained as coaches. Over the course of this General Convention the bishops and deputies will meet three times to share their individual stories of self, us, and now.

These conversations are not ends in themselves, but rather the beginning of a wider conversation engaging the whole church in a process of Public Narrative. From this convention, Deputies and Bishops and members of the ECW will carry on these conversations in the parishes and deaneries and convocations of their own dioceses. Our hope is that more leaders will be raised up who, through telling their story of self, us, and now in community, will enable the Episcopal Church at all levels to turn our outward to mission in the local community and the world.

Wednesday, July 8, 2009

From General Convention

Editor's note: During the General Convention, members of the Central Pennsylvania deputation are providing daily updates to the Diocese. The Rev. Christine Purcell is serving as “recorder and reporter” for these updates. This is the first of those reports.

DAY 1: Tuesday, July 7, 2009

Committee work has begun so that the legislation will reach the floors of the House of Bishops and the House of Deputies early in the Convention. Members of our deputation have been engaged in the various committees they are assigned to or they are following.

We gathered in our table groups to hear opening remarks by Presiding Bishop Katherine Jefferts-Schori and President of the House of Deputies Bonnie Anderson. Schori spoke about crisis and opportunity. Anderson’s focus was mission. Quotable quotes: “This crisis is a decision point –one which may involve suffering. But it is our opportunity to choose which direction we’ll go and what we will build…there will be cross-shaped decisions in our work , but if we look faithfully, there will be resurrection as well” (Jefferts-Schori); “The church does not have a mission. God’s mission has a church” (Anderson).

Professor Marshall Kanz introduced the Public Narrative project, a story-telling based tool to inform our table conversations about Mission. Public Narrative is a model that seeks to mobilize the moral commitment that leads to social change. Kanz teaches at the John F. Kennedy School of Government at Harvard University. The son of a Jewish rabbi, he left home, Bakersfield, CA in 1960, to enter Harvard as a freshman. He dropped out before his senior year to go to Mississippi and work as a civil rights organizer. From there he went back to California and worked with Cesar Chavez for sixteen years. He returned to Harvard after 25 years to complete senior year, graduate studies, and now teaches there.

Public narrative works at the intersection between our individual stories, the stories of our faith communities, and the story of our national (or global) community. The motivation to work for cultural and social change comes out of the engagement of our emotions in hopeful vision of an alternative reality to the present.

There will be three more table sessions through the course of the convention which will use Public Narrative as a method for visioning mission. Prof. Kanz has trained coaches at the Province level who are at many of the tables to facilitate process. The Rev. Stephen Casey and the Rev. David Lovelace have received this training.

Reports from members of the Deputation at the end of the day:

From the Small Church Committee (Kate Harrigan and Gina Barrett)
There is no “national church” – we (small churches) are the church.
A resolution to watch – B006 – concerning the condition of detention centers for immigrants.

Communications (Brian Amato picked this up in casual conversation)
The idea of Episcopal Life going to a glossy quarterly (vs. continuing monthly publication) is up against serious opposition from those concerned about the cost of this strategy in terms in terms of the sense of immediacy and connection to the life of the church for many Episcopalians; particularly in dioceses where large contingents have left TEC.

Consecration of Bishops (Harry Snell)
They have passed on two elected candidates for bishop, the Rev. Larry Provenzano from the Diocese of Long Island and the Rev. John Tarrant from South Dakota. Some paperwork is still needed for the Rev. Ruiz from the Diocese of Ecuador – that should be completed Wednesday morning. He is expected to pass as well.

Civil Air Patrol (Bill Alford)
The Discernment Committee for the next suffragan bishop for federal chaplaincies is working on a profile. Bishop Baxter is chairing this committee.

The requirements for this position are daunting - the person selected must be in really good health, as his/her ministry field is the whole world, and needs to provide oversight to many constituencies: all chaplains in all armed forces, prison chaplains, VA hospital chaplains, and civil air patrol chaplains. The position is open to all clergy.

Ministry (David Lovelace)
There are questions about how some changes to constitutions and canons around ministry development are going to be funded – particularly with respect to theological education and Fresh Start. People are coming out of seminary with significant debt and no way to pay it back. A number of resolutions are being put forward around the funding questions.

Constitutions and Canons (Stephen Casey)
The Standing Committee on Constitution and Canons reviews proposed amendments to the Constitution and Canons of the Episcopal Church and places them in proper form before passing them on to the General Convention for action. In addition they carry out a continual review of current Canons of the Church. At its first meeting of the Convention the Legislative Committee discussed at length the revision to Title IV, which is a major review of the Disciplinary Canons of the Church. The Disciplinary Canons as they now stand were originally set down in 1994. The prevailing attitude to clergy misconduct in those days was to consider it in the same terms as criminal law, in a punitive way. The current revision to go before the house approaches the Disciplinary Canons in a more pastoral and theological manner, moving them towards a reconciliation model for all appropriate circumstances. Later in the day the Committee discussed amendments to the Constitution and Canons that refer to the keeping of archival materials of the church, specifically how these are now garnered from dioceses and provinces of the church in an increasingly electronic age. They also considered amendments to the Canons which refer to the manner in which Diocesan Standing Committees transmit consents for Episcopal Elections.

Bishop Baxter spoke about work on a charter for Christian formation and lifelong learning for lay and ordained persons.

Sunday, July 5, 2009

Watch This Space

The General Convention of the Episcopal Church begins in Anaheim later this week. Members of the Diocesan deputation will be providing daily reports of their activities here, via emails to diocesan clergy, and on the diocesan web site.

Stay tuned for more...